Correct Answer: Correct answer is: (D) All of these.
Exam Relevance: UPSC, IAS, Civil Services, Philosophy Exams
Difficulty: Moderate
Concept notes: The Charvaka school of philosophy, known for its materialistic and atheistic views, often criticized the authority and validity of the Vedas and other scriptures. Various schools of Indian philosophy, including Nyaya, Samkhya, and Advaita Vedanta, have challenged these criticisms by defending the authority and validity of the scriptures.
Common Mistakes: Students may mistakenly believe that only one school of philosophy challenged the Charvaka criticism, rather than multiple schools.
Explanations: The Charvaka school's criticism of scriptures has been challenged by multiple schools of Indian philosophy. Nyaya, a school of logic and epistemology, has defended the validity of the scriptures through logical arguments. Samkhya, a dualistic philosophy, has also defended the authority of the scriptures by emphasizing the importance of knowledge derived from them. Advaita Vedanta, a monistic philosophy, has challenged the Charvaka criticism by asserting the ultimate reality of the Vedas and their teachings. Therefore, all of these schools have challenged the Charvaka criticism of scriptures.
Option Analysis: - Option A: Nyaya has challenged the Charvaka criticism by defending the validity of the scriptures through logical arguments.
- Option B: Samkhya has challenged the Charvaka criticism by emphasizing the importance of knowledge derived from the scriptures.
- Option C: Advaita Vedanta has challenged the Charvaka criticism by asserting the ultimate reality of the Vedas and their teachings.
- Option D: All of these schools have challenged the Charvaka criticism of scriptures.
Mnemonic: N-S-A (Nyaya, Samkhya, Advaita)